Endings

[extrapenguin]

(But! The Guardian rewatchalong has yet to end. Episode 35, with time travel talk!)

Observation of the day: Other people seem to have a much higher tolerance for fairytale endings than I do; I find a lot of the more wish-fulfillment-y ones unrealistic and prefer stuff like "no matter what the rules are, you can live happily within them" to "if the author likes you, the rules will go out the window for your HEA". Perhaps primarily because the former is a thing that can happen while the latter is not applicable to reality.

(By "the rules go out the window", I mean stuff like e.g. a slash ship in a royalty arranged marriage AU in a world where there is no mpreg, no sexual nonexclusivity to create an heir with a concubine, and no stuff to handwave away the lack of biokid heirs, whether that be worldbuilding so that the monarchy is nonhereditary or simply a mention of there being a convenient nephew for them to adopt. There are lots and lots of other ways to go full fairytale in a fashion that I find unbelievable, but this scenario is perhaps the easiest to explain.)

Comments

[extrapenguin]

I think a lot of people who do the big AUs (like, big changes from canon) do so because the AU itself is a bit of a kink? An id thing? I don't quite know what to call it, but basically, I think the AU is the end goal rather than the set dressing
Ah, yeah, a narrative kink! I admit I don't share the kink for setting change AUs, either. (A bunch of the modern AU ones I've read are also deeply OOC because of the thing you mention: character X would never be content as a Starbucks barista without at the very least some ambitions of getting out of there, etc.)

It's probably really telling that most of the big-changes AU fics I've enjoyed are for canons I'm not familiar with!
Probably! The more one knows, the more one can notice the discrepancies and missed opportunities.

A one-off discussion between your arranged spouses that mentions, "after the engagement I'll officially designate my eldest cousin as my heir, which removes the last impediment to the union" doesn't need a twelve-chapter explanation of how the lines of descent or legal requirements for royal marriage work in this universe; the reader can extrapolate enough to go on with.
Plus eleventy billion. Worldbuilding is wonderful, but it's also reasonably easy to do the minimal handwaving that results in an impression that the characters have thought it through.

[krait]

Yep, I really think it's a case of narrative kink at play in about half of the cases, if not more. And yep, "badly translated" characters - where their canonical personality doesn't mesh with their AU placement - throw me out of a story really quickly. Some characters just really, really don't fit into some settings, not without such extreme changes that you're basically designing an OC. (I ran into this a lot in Yuuri on Ice fandom, where AUs were rife and often based on 'whatever cute idea is circulating on Tumblr today' rather than any ability to parallel the canon characters' personalities and dynamics.)

Plus eleventy billion. Worldbuilding is wonderful, but it's also reasonably easy to do the minimal handwaving that results in an impression that the characters have thought it through.

Yes. I'd add that what's most important is that the author has thought it through - no matter how much or how little explanation makes it into the fic, the author should have worked out the basic problems and how they were solved. If the author is working from a plan, the fic will have internal logic that holds up through the fic, even if the solutions happened offscreen. If not, they're probably going to trip up somewhere and give out conflicting information or leave gaps in the plot.

[extrapenguin]

Some characters just really, really don't fit into some settings, not without such extreme changes that you're basically designing an OC.
+1 I ran into it a lot in MDZS fandom – though to be fair, a lot of the allegedly canon setting fic also had very ... interesting characterization choices.

I'd add that what's most important is that the author has thought it through - no matter how much or how little explanation makes it into the fic, the author should have worked out the basic problems and how they were solved.
Oh, yes, this, definitely! Forays of fandoms past have revealed that there are people who don't even think about thinking it through; after getting started in Vorkosigan fandom, it was quite a shock. :P (Hm, this is probably also part of what underpins my dislike of Trope Product fic, where there's a trope that comes with a plot already and then that plot is hewed to to the beat, scarcely more than a search-and-replace needed *g* The lack of thinking leaves the plot with gaps or conflicts in the information.)